Forex Spreads and Commissions Explained
Understand trading cost structures and choose the most cost-effective conditions
What is a Spread?
The spread is the difference between the buying price (Ask) and selling price (Bid) in forex trading, a cost traders must pay on every position opened.
Example:
EUR/USD Quote:
- Ask Price: 1.1003
- Bid Price: 1.1000
- Spread: 3 pips
This means: you buy at 1.1003, but can immediately sell only at 1.1000, instantly losing 3 pips. These 3 pips are the trading cost paid to your broker.
Monetary Value of Spreads
Spread costs vary by currency pair and lot size:
- EUR/USD, 3-pip spread, 1 standard lot: $30
- GBP/USD, 2-pip spread, 1 standard lot: $20
- USD/JPY, 1.5-pip spread, 1 standard lot: $15
💡 For day traders making 10 trades daily, spread costs alone could reach $150-$300!
While seemingly small, spreads are one of the largest cost factors for frequent day traders and scalpers. Choosing a low-spread broker can significantly improve long-term profitability.
Fixed vs Floating Spreads
Fixed Spread
Features:
- Spread remains constant regardless of market conditions
- Broker assumes market volatility risk
- Typically slightly higher than average floating spread
✅ Advantages:
- Predictable costs, easy P&L calculation
- Spreads won't suddenly widen during major news
- Suitable for beginners and scalpers
❌ Disadvantages:
- May be higher than floating spreads during normal markets
- Brokers may suspend trading during extreme conditions
Floating Spread
Features:
- Spread varies in real-time with market liquidity
- Reflects real market supply and demand
- Narrows during high liquidity, widens during low liquidity
✅ Advantages:
- Lower spreads during normal market conditions
- More transparent, reflects real market conditions
- Suitable for trend trading and longer-term positions
❌ Disadvantages:
- Unpredictable costs, difficult to calculate precisely
- Spreads can spike to 10-50 pips during major news
- Not suitable for scalping strategies
💡 Which to Choose?
- Beginners, scalpers → Fixed spreads (controlled costs, easier learning)
- Trend traders, swing traders → Floating spreads (lower long-term costs)
- News avoiders → Either works, but avoid data release periods
Commission Models: Commission-Free vs Commission-Based
Beyond spreads, some brokers charge trading commissions. Understanding the difference is crucial for account selection:
Commission-Free Account
Broker profits through spreads, no additional commission.
Cost Example:
- EUR/USD spread: 3 pips
- Commission: $0
- Total cost: $30 (spread only)
✅ Suitable for: Beginners, long-term traders, small accounts
Commission-Based Account
Lower spreads, but charges fixed commission per trade (typically $3-$7/lot).
Cost Example:
- EUR/USD spread: 0.5 pips
- Commission: $7 (round-trip)
- Total cost: $12 ($5 spread + $7 commission)
✅ Suitable for: Day traders, scalpers, high-frequency traders
⚠️ Key Insight: Which is Cheaper?
For major pairs (EUR/USD, GBP/USD), commission accounts typically have lower total costs. For cross and exotic pairs, commission-free may be cheaper. Calculate actual total costs (spread + commission) before deciding.
Account Type Comparison: MM, STP, ECN
| Type | Full Name | Spread | Commission | Execution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MM | Market Maker | Fixed, higher | None | Internal broker matching |
| STP | Straight Through Processing | Floating, medium | Usually none | Direct to liquidity providers |
| ECN | Electronic Communication Network | Floating, very low | Yes ($3-7/lot) | Direct to interbank market |
MM Account (Market Maker)
Broker acts as your counterparty. Suitable for beginners, but potential conflict of interest (your losses may be broker's profits).
STP Account (Straight Through Processing)
Orders sent directly to liquidity providers without dealing desk intervention. More transparent, suitable for intermediate traders.
ECN Account (Electronic Communication Network)
Most transparent model, your orders matched with global banks and hedge funds. Lowest spreads, fastest execution, but charges commission. Suitable for professional traders and high-frequency strategies.
Trading Cost Calculation & Optimization
Complete Cost Calculation Formula
Total cost per trade =
Spread cost + Commission + Slippage cost + Swap (if overnight)
Real Case: Day Trader Cost Analysis
Assumptions: Day trader, 10 EUR/USD trades daily, 1 lot each, over 1 month (20 trading days)
Broker A (Commission-Free)
- Spread: 3 pips = $30
- Commission: $0
- Cost per trade: $30
- Monthly cost: $30 × 10 × 20 = $6,000
Broker B (ECN Account)
- Spread: 0.5 pips = $5
- Commission: $7
- Cost per trade: $12
- Monthly cost: $12 × 10 × 20 = $2,400
💰 Conclusion: Broker B saves $3,600 monthly (60% cost reduction)!
For high-frequency traders, choosing a low-cost broker is a key profitability factor.
Cost Optimization Strategies
- Choose appropriate account type: ECN for high-frequency, standard for long-term
- Trade during high liquidity: Tighter spreads, less slippage
- Avoid major news: Prevent spread spikes and slippage
- Consolidate trading frequency: Reduce overtrading, improve trade quality
- Regularly compare brokers: Competitive market may offer better options
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Are lower spreads always better?▼
Not necessarily. While low spreads reduce trading costs, consider other factors: broker regulation, order execution quality, slippage, withdrawal speed, etc. Some ultra-low spread brokers may have issues in other areas. We recommend comprehensive evaluation, choosing brokers with reasonable spreads and quality overall service.
Q2: Fixed or floating spreads - which is better?▼
Depends on trading style. Fixed spreads suit beginners and scalpers - costs are predictable and won't suddenly widen during data releases. Floating spreads can be lower during normal markets, suitable for trend and swing trading. But they widen significantly during major news. Beginners should start with fixed spreads.
Q3: Are ECN accounts truly better than standard accounts?▼
ECN accounts offer more transparent market pricing and faster execution, typically lower spreads, but charge commissions. Suitable for day trading and scalping strategies, and experienced traders. Standard accounts have no commission but slightly higher spreads, better for beginners and long-term traders. Choose based on your trading frequency and style.
Q4: How do I calculate my actual trading costs?▼
Total cost = Spread cost + Commission + Slippage + Overnight interest (if holding positions). Example: Trading 1 standard lot EUR/USD, 2 pip spread, $7 commission, 0.5 pip slippage, total open+close cost ~$32. Formula: (Spread+Slippage) × Lots × Contract size × Pip value + Commission. Track real costs per trade in Excel.
Q5: Is sudden spread widening broker manipulation?▼
Usually not. Spread widening typically occurs during: 1) Major economic data releases; 2) Market open/close; 3) Low liquidity periods (late night); 4) Sudden major events. This is normal market behavior. However, if spreads frequently widen abnormally far beyond industry standards, consider changing brokers.
Related Learning Resources
Want Better Trading Conditions?
FX Killer partner brokers offer highly competitive spreads and commissions